Nightmare

30th Anniversary Edition (2022), Magic: The Gathering, #412, Rare, art by Melissa A. Benson. TCGplayer product name: Nightmare (Retro Frame)

Nightmare
PrintingNormal

No current market price. Last tracked TCGplayer price, Jul 22 (98 days ago).

Buy on TCGplayerSearch on eBay

Affiliate links. Qualifying purchases may earn tcgvibes.com a commission.

Price trend

Jul 15 $80.00 → Jul 22, 2026 $80.00

$80.00
Jul 15, 2026Jul 17, 2026Jul 18, 2026Jul 19, 2026Jul 22, 2026

Jun 22 $80.00 → Jul 22, 2026 $80.00

$80.00
Jun 22, 2026Jul 2, 2026Jul 7, 2026Jul 12, 2026Jul 22, 2026

Apr 23 $80.00 → Jul 22, 2026 $80.00

$80.00
Apr 23, 2026May 23, 2026Jun 7, 2026Jun 22, 2026Jul 22, 2026

Jul 22, 2025 $160 → Jul 22, 2026 $80.00

$160$100$120$140$80.00
Jul 22, 2025Nov 20, 2025Jan 20, 2026Mar 22, 2026Jul 22, 2026

Feb 8, 2024 $350 → Jul 22, 2026 $80.00 −77.1%

$350$200$300$80.00
Feb 8, 2024Dec 2, 2024Apr 30, 2025Sep 26, 2025Jul 22, 2026
Market details

Sold vs asking

Sellers asking (median listing)$245

Asking figure from TCGplayer listings, as of Oct 24.

Record

Price history Feb 8, 2024 to Jul 22, 2026

Highest$350Feb 8, 2024 to Apr 8, 2024
Lowest$80.00Jan 23, 2026 to Jul 22, 2026 (last tracked)

Change

Latest change−50.0%Jan 23, $159.99 (Aug 29, 2025) → $80.00

Same set: 30th Anniversary Edition (594)

Blaze of Glory$0.25Death Ward$0.46Ancestral RecallPhantasmal Forces$0.99Pirate Ship

Same artist: Melissa A. Benson (196)

About Face$0.13The List

Keep exploring

Same artistMore by Melissa A. BensonSame setMore from 30th Anniversary EditionThe methodResearchGamesAll Magic: The Gathering setsTodayBiggest moves in Magic: The Gathering

Live market

Last tracked TCGplayer value: Jul 22, 2026. Prices in USD. Card names and images © their respective publishers. See how these prices are made.