Nightmare

Eighth Edition, Magic: The Gathering, #150, Rare, art by Carl Critchlow

Nightmare
PrintingNormal $0.57Foil $4.73

Foil, Near Mint

$4.73

TCGplayer market price (an average of recent sales)

As of Oct 24 (3 days ago). Unchanged across this 30-day window.

Buy on TCGplayerSearch on eBay

Affiliate links. Qualifying purchases may earn tcgvibes.com a commission.

Price trend

For the Foil printing.

Oct 17 $4.73 → Oct 24, 2026 $4.73 0.0%

$4.73
Oct 17, 2026Oct 19, 2026Oct 20, 2026Oct 21, 2026Oct 24, 2026

Sep 24 $4.73 → Oct 24, 2026 $4.73 0.0%

$4.73
Sep 24, 2026Oct 4, 2026Oct 9, 2026Oct 14, 2026Oct 24, 2026

Jul 27 $11.94 → Oct 24, 2026 $4.73 −60.4%

$11.94$6.00$8.00$10.00$4.73
Jul 27, 2026Aug 25, 2026Sep 9, 2026Sep 24, 2026Oct 24, 2026

Oct 27, 2025 $2.03 → Oct 24, 2026 $4.73

$11.94$1.73$4.00$6.00$8.00$4.73
Oct 27, 2025Feb 24, 2026Apr 26, 2026Jun 25, 2026Oct 24, 2026

Feb 8, 2024 $4.12 → Oct 24, 2026 $4.73 +14.8%

$11.94$1.73$4.00$6.00$8.00$4.73
Feb 8, 2024Jan 2, 2025Jun 16, 2025Nov 28, 2025Oct 24, 2026
Market details

Sold vs asking

Recent sales (TCGplayer market price)$4.73
Sellers asking (median listing, Foil)$15.00
0$15.00

Sellers ask 3.2× the recent sale price.

Asking figure from TCGplayer listings, as of Oct 24.

Record

Price history Feb 8, 2024 to Oct 24, 2026

Highest (Foil)$11.94Jan 30, 2026
Lowest (Foil)$1.73Jan 14, 2026
Vs highest60% below $11.94

Printings

PrintingMarketListed median
Foil (the price shown above)$4.73$15.00
Normal$0.57$0.50

Other versions of this card (2)

Nightmare$0.19Ninth EditionNightmare$99.99Seventh Edition

Same set: Eighth Edition (710)

Angelic Page$0.10Aven Cloudchaser$0.32Elite Javelineer$0.06

Same artist: Carl Critchlow (568)

Fiend Artisan$6.51Special GuestsChastise$0.15The ListPhyrexian Gargantua$0.07The ListJedit Ojanen of Efrava$2.37The List

Keep exploring

Same artistMore by Carl CritchlowSame setMore from Eighth EditionThe methodResearchGamesAll Magic: The Gathering setsTodayBiggest moves in Magic: The Gathering

Live market

Newest TCGplayer value: Oct 24, 2026. Prices in USD. Card names and images © their respective publishers. See how these prices are made.