Once Upon a Time

The List, Magic: The Gathering, 169/269, Rare, art by Matt Stewart

Once Upon a Time

Printing: Normal · Near Mint

$1.32

TCGplayer market price (an average of recent sales)

As of Oct 17 (4 days ago).

Listed median$1.37asks on TCGplayer as of Oct 17

Change

7d−2.2% −$0.0330d−2.9% −$0.0490d−5.0% −$0.071y—
Buy on TCGplayerSearch on eBay

Affiliate links. Qualifying purchases may earn tcgvibes.com a commission.

Related cards

Ardent Plea$1.43Same setWill Kenrith$1.31Same setAkroma, Angel of Wrath$2.11Same setCopySame setAn Unexpected Party // At the Door$0.27Same artistKnightly Valor$0.16Same artist

Price trend

Oct 10 $1.35 → Oct 17, 2026 $1.32 −2.2%

$1.37$1.34$1.36$1.32
Oct 10, 2026Oct 12, 2026Oct 13, 2026Oct 14, 2026Oct 17, 2026

Sep 17 $1.36 → Oct 17, 2026 $1.32 −2.9%

$1.37$1.30$1.34$1.36$1.32
Sep 17, 2026Sep 27, 2026Oct 2, 2026Oct 7, 2026Oct 17, 2026

Jul 19 $1.39 → Oct 17, 2026 $1.32 −5.0%

$1.40$1.26$1.30$1.35$1.32
Jul 19, 2026Aug 18, 2026Sep 2, 2026Sep 17, 2026Oct 17, 2026

Oct 17, 2025 $1.43 → Oct 17, 2026 $1.32

$3.68$1.24low$2.00$3.00$1.32
Oct 17, 2025Feb 15, 2026Apr 17, 2026Jun 17, 2026Oct 17, 2026

Feb 8, 2024 $0.64 → Oct 17, 2026 $1.32 +106%

$3.68$0.62$1.00$2.00$3.00$1.32
Feb 8, 2024Dec 31, 2024Jun 13, 2025Nov 23, 2025Oct 17, 2026

Record

Price history Feb 8, 2024 to Oct 17, 2026

Highest before release$3.68Oct 27, 2025
Highest since release$1.62May 28, 2026
Lowest$0.62Feb 10, 2024
Vs highest since release19% below $1.62

Price changes, last 30 days

DatePriceChange
Sep 23$1.34 → $1.30−3.0%Show on chart
Sep 27$1.30 → $1.32+1.5%Show on chart
Oct 7$1.32 → $1.35+2.3%Show on chart
Oct 11$1.35 → $1.37+1.5%Show on chart
Oct 14$1.37 → $1.35−1.5%Show on chart
Oct 17$1.35 → $1.32−2.2%Show on chart

Latest 6 of 7.

Vs its set

Over the 90 days to Oct 17, 2026: this card −5.0%; the median other printing in The List 0.0% (4,996 other printings). 4,601 of those 4,996 changed price, but no more than half rose and no more than half fell, so the middle change is 0%.

Keep exploring

Same artistMore by Matt StewartSame setMore from The ListThe methodResearchGamesAll Magic: The Gathering setsTodayBiggest moves in Magic: The Gathering

Live market

Newest TCGplayer value: Oct 17, 2026. Prices in USD. Card names and images © their respective publishers. See how these prices are made.